Wednesday, May 19, 2010

Food Deserts

Although I try to make time to pack a lunch each day, there are a few mornings here and there when I find myself rushing out the door empty-handed. Fortunately, being a librarian is flexible enough that on those days I can usually leave for a few minutes to run and get something to eat for lunch. My school is located deep in the heart of South Dallas where the lunch options within 10 minutes drive include McDonalds, Jack in the Box, a couple of fried chicken establishments, and a couple of local BBQ hole in the walls. The only grocery store within 5-6 miles (estimated) is Minyards...one grocery store serving all of South Dallas. Less than desirable produce and fresh meat coupled with high prices from lack of competition characterize South Dallas's only option for grocery shopping.

Fortunately for me, I can get in a car and drive the 15 minutes to a part of town that has quality grocery stores and restaurants with healthy options. Many people in South Dallas don't have that option. A large percent of the population here relies on public transportation and city buses. I hate lugging my 10-15 grocery bags up one flight of stairs each week. I can't imagine toting all of that through multiple stops and exchanges on a DART bus. No wonder its easier (and cheaper) to walk across the street to the liquor/corner store and buy a $.99 bag of hot chips.

Every day I see my students come into school with a bag of chips, candy, and soda. Every day I see them skip lunch in the cafeteria (school lunches have gotten just ridiculous...very poor quality food, tiny servings, and not worth the $2-3 paid for it) and opt for those type of nutritionally void snacks. After school, they visit the corner store again for more chips or maybe fork over their change to the rattly ice cream truck that is always rolling through the neighborhoods. Fresh fruits and vegetables are practically non-existent in this area, even in the school lunches that may be the only "meal" that some kids are given each day.

I read an article that describes this problem, sometimes called "food deserts." The introductory paragraph sounded all too familiar....

It's easier to buy fried chicken, red pop, and flaming-hot potato chips than it is to find an apple in certain middle-to-low income Black neighborhoods. In fact, visit a certain side of Any City, U.S.A., and you are likely to find the four corners of any given intersection occupied by a fast-food restaurant, a convenience store selling penny candy, a liqour store, and a fried chicken shack.

What's missing from this picture is a store selling high-quality fresh produce, such as apples, collard greens or broccoli; a store that is affordable and that is not four miles away. Does what's missing sound familiar?

Welcome to the food desert.

In Chicago, approximately 633,000 people, in a city with a population of 3 million, live in neighborhoods that lack a grocery store. Roughly half of Detroit's residents live in an area devoid of a mainstream full-service supermarket, leaving 460,000 people, who without a car or food-delivery service, don't have access to fresh fruit and vegetables. We can throw many more cities with the same problems into the mix. Memphis, Kansas City, St. Louis, Indianapolis, Baltimore, Atlanta, Richmond, Los Angeles, Philadelphia, and New Orleans. (And Dallas!)

Food deserts are inextricably linked to a host of medical issues in our communities, chief among them diabetes and obesity. Simply put, if we ant to live longer, then we will have to eat better. To eat better, we need better food choices. Better food choices come from watering the food desert.


You know, I read a lot of the health and fitness magazines when I'm working out at the gym and they invariably have recipes and ideas for healthy eating that include all kinds of fruits, vegetables, grains, and cheeses that I've never heard of. I would probably have to go to Whole Foods or Central Market to find some of these things, and then pay out the nose for them. I'm a single, employed young professional who honestly cannot afford some of the most healthy stuff out there...eating healthy is not cheap! So I can only imagine if I were on a very limited income with limited transportation...healthy eating becomes an almost insurmountable challenge.

Are the people in South Dallas and neighborhoods like this so invaluable to our society that their health is of no importance to us or our economy? Are they not worth the investment of grocery stores and establishments that would give them options for food that could enhance their health and give them longer lives? Is health, like education and so many other things, just a privilege of the wealthy? People in South Dallas have to eat too. They have money to spend on food...many even have government assistance, such as food stamps. But they have nowhere to spend it. Wouldn't it be better use of government assistance if they could swipe their Lone Star card at Tom Thumb for some fresh fruit, veggies, and meat instead of at the corner store for some chips and soda? Without having to catch three buses and a train to get there? Even for those who can only be convinced by economical reasoning, the medical problems that result from lack of healthy eating only serve to inevitably place an enormous burden on taxpayers in the future, since many of the same people who don't have access to healthy food also may not have access to health insurance or medical/preventative care.

I know the reasons that food deserts exist are deeper and more complex than I can fully understand. But I do believe that solutions are out there. I do believe there are people who understand the systemic complexities and have the ability and power to make changes that can alter the status quo. People look at neighborhoods like South Dallas and have a million opinions and stereotypes about why the community is like this and why people aren't doing better. But there are also a million challenges that they've never had to even think about that these neighbors deal with on a daily basis, one of which is just figuring out how to put a decent meal on the table. I think it is important to just educate ourselves and be more aware of some of the obstacles that exist in neighborhoods like this and think about what we can do to advocate to eliminate some of those inequities.

What can our city do to eliminate food deserts? What can we do to bring healthy food back into forgotten neighborhoods? What can we do to show our neighbors here that we truly believe that they are important to us, that their health is important to us, that their right to a quality life is important to us? What can we do to ensure that the children in South Dallas aren't just taught about the nutritional pyramid in school but that they have the opportunity to put that knowledge into practice? When we strengthen a neglected part of our society, we strengthen our society as a whole. Solutions are out there...but does our city/state/nation care enough to find them?

4 comments:

  1. I have read articles that say prisons are serving healthier meals than what school children are eating.
    As for healthy eating, I recently read an article that talked about how you can eat healthy by buying foods that are less than $1 a lb. Healthy eating does not have to be expensive. Beans,legumes, many vegetables and fruits can be bought for $1 lb or under. Of course if you do not have a grocery store close to you this doesn't mean anything. But I thought it was interesting and enlightening none the less.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Putting my 'free marketer' thinking cap on, I would say the reason there are no convenient grocery stores in your neighborhood is because they were not being patronized. At least not at a level to support their existence. There were corner groceries in the past right? Where have they gone? And why have fast foods sprang up in their place? That is what the people in that part of town have voted for with their money. You said it, they have money for food, that is what they have chosen to buy with it. I would bet if you put in a small basic grocery store (with reasonable priced goods) right next to the fast food joint it would not be able to stay in business. People nowadays want convenience, over substance or quality. They don't want to fix a healthy supper. That is the root of the problem. So much of our citizens don't care about their health, until it is too late.....

    -not saying everybody in that part of town is that way, I really understand the frustration a person would have to go through to actually eat healthy and fix their own meals. I'm saying it is the way society has evolved, and the turn away from the traditional corner grocery that has resulted.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I disagree. Ive been to a lot of different type of community meetings where residents are voicing what they would like to see change in the area and almost always several people will mention a decent, affordable grocery store at the top of the list. Most residents of South Dallas do patronize grocery stores....they just have to travel a great distance to do so. White flight from inner city neighborhoods over the past few decades is a big reason those corner grocery stores no longer exist...they followed out to the suburbs. And the only businesses that were willing to step in were those fast food restaurants and liquor stores. I read a report about food deserts and some of the economic factors and this report found that it would actually be less costly for a typical supermarket to operate in a low-income neighborhood and possibly of greater profit because of lack of competition...so the question is why do no supermarkets choose to move in? I don't think it is fair to assume that the residents of South Dallas wouldn't support a grocery store in their neighborhood...they support the Minyards very well. It's just that they don't have a choice. People in suburban areas can choose between Kroger, Albertsons, Walmart, and Tom Thumb within just a few blocks of each other. They can compare prices and shop around and have options. People in South Dallas don't have those options and I don't believe it is because they don't want them or wouldn't support them. The residents of South Dallas didn't put the corner grocery stores out of business....all the people who moved to the suburbs did. But they've never stopped wanting convenient, affordable shopping options and just need someone to invest in their community again. Another major store means jobs...something else that can help play a role in revitalizing the overall landscape. Almost every teenager I know goes to apply for a job at Minyards when they turn 15 because that's one of the only businesses in South Dallas. But Minyards can't hire them all. Anyways, I think its much deeper than just simple supply and demand here. Because there is a demand but no supply.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Well..... me and you think very differently obviously.

    It is very rare in our economy that a demand for a product is not filled. The corner/small time/regular grocery stores of the past did not pack up and move to the suburbs just because they felt like it. They quit making a profit at some point and couldn't keep the doors open. My question is why? I can imagine all kinds of reasons, but the most obvious is they did not have enough customers. Could be it was too expensive to hire help? Or too expensive to get fresh groceries in that part of town? Too much crime/vandalism/shoplifting? Cost too much to have a building there due to property tax or zoning issues? Probably a plethora of reasons that I can't begin to understand. AND problems that could possibly be overcome. But I do understand that fast food companies can keep businesses open, and even start up new ones.

    I read a report about food deserts and some of the economic factors and this report found that it would actually be less costly for a typical supermarket to operate in a low-income neighborhood and possibly of greater profit because of lack of competition...

    If this was possible, there would be some enterprising entrepreneur scrambling to break ground and build a new store.

    The dollar store segment of out retail economy is one of the fastest growing businesses right now. I heard Dollar General is building 600+ new stores this year. Now why is that? People are going in the doors and buying their stuff. We sure do our share! Saves us lots of trips to Walmart. Now is the Dollar General doing that just for good will? No, it is a business that makes money while providing a service. IF and only IF people come in and buy things.

    If I had the money I would build a DG in Bovina because I know it would do good. I don't care what the town or the people look like or how much money they have. It is a niche that needs filled and would likely work.

    ReplyDelete